Table of contents
So, you’re ready to fulfill the mitzvah of sitting in the Sukkah this Sukkot . You’ve built the perfect temporary dwelling, lovingly covered it with Schach , and maybe even hung a decorative pomegranate or two. But now the questions start rolling in. What if you’re exempt? Can you duck into the house if it rains? Do women really have to eat in the Sukkah? Let’s dive into these age-old halachic debates with a smile and some clarity.
Who’s Off the Hook? Exemptions from the Sukkah
Ah, the age-old halachic dilemma: Teishvu k’ein taduru – "dwell in the Sukkah as you would at home." That’s the guiding principle behind the mitzvah of Sukkah , but what if the Sukkah becomes a place of misery instead of joy? Enter the exemptions.
The Basics: Who’s Automatically Off the Hook?
According to the Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chayim 640:1), certain groups are exempt from the mitzvah of Sukkah :
Women : Since the mitzvah is a mitzvat aseh she’hazman grama (a positive time-bound commandment), women aren’t obligated.
Children : Kids who are too young to not rely on their mother are exempt. The Mishnah Berurah (640:4) pegs this at about age five or six.
Sick people and their caregivers : If sitting in the Sukkah causes discomfort or aggravates an illness, you’re out. Even the Rambam (Laws of Shofar, Sukkah, and Lulav 6:2) agrees: mitzvot are meant to be joyful, not painful.
Rain, Rain, Go Away
What if the weather doesn’t cooperate? The Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chayim 639:5) lays it out: if it rains hard enough that your soup tastes like rainwater (mitzta’er – causing discomfort), you’re allowed to pack it up and head inside. The Talmud (Sukkah 28b) likens staying in the Sukkah under such conditions to a servant bringing their master a drink only to have it thrown in their face. In other words, G-d is saying, “Not now, buddy.”
But be careful not to jump ship at the first drizzle – especially not if it rains on the first night of Sukkot. A little sprinkle doesn’t cut it for a Sukkah exemption unless it’s ruining your food or sleep.
Can I Put Up a Tarp or Tent?
Now let’s tackle the great tarp debate. If it’s pouring rain , can you cover your Sukkah with a tarp and wait out the storm? The short answer: technically, yes, but it’s complicated.
The Mishnah Berurah (629:18) explains that while it’s fine to protect your Sukkah from damage, eating under the tarp doesn’t count as fulfilling the mitzvah. Why? Because the Schach – the natural roof of the Sukkah – has to be the thing shading you, not some plastic Costco special.
That said, there’s nothing wrong with protecting your Sukkah so it’s ready to go once the rain lets up. And there are arrays of weatherproof Sukkahs to choose from these days, so you even avoid the tarp altogether. Pro tip: keep a good book inside so you’re ready to cozy up the moment the skies clear.
Do Women Have to Eat in the Sukkah?
Here’s where things get a little tricky – and a lot interesting. Women, as we mentioned earlier, have a Sukkah exemption from the mitzvah of sitting in the Sukkah. But does that mean they shouldn’t eat there?
The Halachic Breakdown
Halachically, women aren’t obligated to sit in the Sukkah , but they earn heavenly reward if they choose to participate (Shulchan Aruch Orach Chayim 640:1). The Ran (Rosh Hashanah 33a) even suggests that women who take on this mitzvah are showing spiritual dedication.
Many women opt to join their families in the Sukkah for the sake of unity. After all, nothing says "domestic tranquility" like sharing a meal in your backyard under a roof made of palm fronds. As the Kaf HaChaim (640:5) points out, sitting in the Sukkah cleanses the soul and brings heavenly merit. Who wouldn’t want that on their Sukkot checklist?
Sleeping in the Sukkah: To Nap or Not to Nap
Eating is one thing, but what about sleeping in the Sukkah? The Rambam (Laws of Shofar, Sukkah, and Lulav 6:6) is pretty clear: both men and women should sleep in the Sukkah as part of the mitzvah. But tradition, practicality, and a healthy fear of spiders have led many to take a more lenient approach.
Some men rely on the principle of mitzta’er (being distressed) to excuse themselves, especially if they live in chilly climates. Women, meanwhile, are exempt altogether but can still partake if they’re feeling brave (or have a really cozy sleeping bag).
When Tradition Meets Comfort
At the end of the day (or the festival), the mitzvah of Sukkah is all about joy. Whether you’re exempt or not , the goal is to make the Sukkah a place of happiness, not a source of stress.
If you’re a woman debating whether to eat in the Sukkah , remember this: while you’re not obligated, your presence adds to the festive atmosphere and brings merit to your soul. If you’re a guy eyeing the weather app, don’t hesitate to duck inside if the rain gets unbearable – just don’t use the Sukkah exemption as an excuse to avoid the Sukkah altogether.
And if all else fails, throw a tarp over your Sukkah , grab a hot drink, and wait for the storm to pass. Sukkot, like life, is about making the best of whatever comes your way.
Happy Sukkot – and may your soup stay rain-free!
